3.0 B4215 2024-04-24 12954036 PP-12954036 2 1 Garden tree OnlineViaPortal 0.00 0.00 GBP 1 12954036-2-1 255267 application/pdf ApplicationForm.pdf A4 0 0 Application Form 12954036-2-2 254932 application/pdf ApplicationFormRedacted.pdf A4 0 0 Application Form - Without Personal Data 12954036-2-3 52209 application/pdf FeeCalculation.pdf A4 0 0 How the fee was calculated 12954036-2-4 104246 application/pdf AttachmentSummary.pdf A4 0 0 A summary of the attachments in the proposal 12954036-2-10 240586 application/pdf AmendmentSummary.pdf A4 0 0 Delta Summary 12954036-2-23703826 3195846 image/jpeg 20240410_173431.jpg Sketch of 19 Victoria Road, including trees put forward for permission, boundary of the property, and adjoining roads and properties Sketch plan 12954036-2-23703896 1034768 image/jpeg Screenshot_20240419_130128_Maps.jpg satellite image with location of trees, property boundary, adjoining roads and properties Sketch plan 12954036-2-23704026 9918668 image/jpeg 20240410_112927.jpg photo of tree 1 Photographs and photomontages 12954036-2-23704046 7628378 image/jpeg 20240410_112907.jpg photo of tree 2 trunk next to fence Photographs and photomontages 12954036-2-23704068 8040670 image/jpeg 20240410_112902.jpg photo of tree 2 Photographs and photomontages 12954036-2-23704161 5743423 image/jpeg 20240410_112911.jpg photo of tree 1 next to house Photographs and photomontages 12954036-2-23704201 7518246 image/jpeg 20240410_112853.jpg photo of tarmac damage caused by tree 2 Photographs and photomontages Caroline Slinger 19 Victoria Road Whalley Range Manchester Manchester United Kingdom M16 8GP caroline.slinger@hotmail.co.uk 07841533633 19 Victoria Road Whalley Range Manchester Manchester Manchester M16 8GP 77086396 382865 394915 31 0 1 1 We have 2 trees on our property that we want to cut down and apparently we have to apply for this because we live in Whalley Range Conservation Area. Both trees were in place when we purchased the property in July 2021. The previous occupants had a proven cavalier attitude towards the planting of trees and not considering how they will impact the property in future, e.g. in the winter of 2022 all electricity to the house was cut off due to the roots of a tree planted by the previous owners damaging the cable carrying electricity into the house. According to the PictureThis app, one probably a Red Tip Photinia and the other is possibly Cherry Plum. The Red Tip Photinia was planted very close to the walls at the rear of the house. The tree has now grown to approximately 5m tall which is a cause for concern for a few reasons. Firstly, safety is a concern because it is growing too close to the structure of the house, risking damage from falling branches or even the entire tree during storms or high winds. Secondly, it can cause structural damage to the house over time, as its roots may infiltrate foundations, causing instability or costly repairs. This concern has been exacerbated recently as we have seen damp and mould in the corner of the kitchen where the tree grows. Lastly, the tree's proximity might hinder necessary maintenance or renovations to my property, limiting access and complicating future construction efforts. Given these considerations, obtaining approval for the tree's removal could safeguard both my property and my family, while facilitating future maintenance and development. The second tree which is possibly Cherry Plum is at the far rear of the property and is planted very close the the rear fence. The trunk is a clear threat to the rear fence and the roots have caused significant visible damage to the tarmac on my driveway. It has grown to approximately 9m tall and is therefore now a threat to my neighbour's property. We believe this should be approved for felling for the following reasons. Firstly, the root system's encroachment presents a clear danger to the structural integrity of both my driveway and fence, risking safety hazards and necessitating costly repairs. Secondly, the tree's expansive growth not only undermines the aesthetic appeal of my property but also compromises its value and functionality, impacting our overall enjoyment and investment. Lastly, the tree's size poses a serious threat to my neighbour's property, potentially leading to damage or injury in the event of falling branches or the tree itself. Removing the tree is crucial to mitigating these risks, ensuring the safety and well-being of both my property and my neighbour's, and preserving the harmony of our community. 0 0 2024-04-24 1 I received a letter from the council saying they were unable to progress my proposal as the application was invalid or incomplete because I hadn't provided a plan (or satellite image) showing the location of the trees. This was patently false as I had certainly included a plan showing the location of the trees. I have now included more attachments including the original plan I sent, along with a satellite image showing the location of the trees and photographs. Given I had attached supporting documents last time and was told I hadn't, my confidence in this process is low. Please ensure you open the supporting documents this time.